
On July 14, 2026, Governor Kathy Hochul announced the first statewide moratorium on new hyperscale data centers. Under her executive order, New York will not issue discretionary environmental permits for new facilities of fifty megawatts or more, while the state scrambles for a solution.
This backlash had been mounting over the last year. In June, voters in Monterey Park, California, passed the country’s first voter-enacted ban on data centers, with 86 percent in favor. By mid-September, lawmakers in sixteen states were considering bans or moratoria of their own.
A moratorium is a blunt response and is, quite literally, not constructive. States should instead establish a Data Center Host Community Framework: a standard arrangement that gives host localities a guaranteed stream of revenue tied to project scale, sets required terms for every development contract, and provides a pathway for enforcing commitments, while allowing developers to build and expand without arbitrary surprises.
Three properties of the status quo make data centers a distinct challenge. First, localities are competing for mobile investment by bidding down their own tax revenue. Second, locals are operating on incomplete and asymmetric information about project outcomes, often with less negotiating experience than the developers across the table. Third, projects are approved in one form but can change long afterward. Consequently, individual disagreements that might otherwise be negotiated with nuance can harden into all-or-nothing fights, or into regional moratoria on projects altogether. There is no denying that, qualitatively, a certain ship has already sailed; the backlash to data centers has taken on a popular and political dimension that development practices will not be able to walk back. But systematic mistakes persist that elected leaders and developers can and should avoid going forward.



