Content

/

Commentary

/

Congress should have reviewed GAO’s vision and followed the process

Commentary

American Governance

Congress should have reviewed GAO’s vision and followed the process

November 19, 2026
The featured image for a post titled "Congress should have reviewed GAO’s vision and followed the process"

The current political controversy over the Comptroller General vacancy illustrates many of the challenges that we discussed in our January report on the Government Accountability Office (GAO).

At the time, we called for hearings to create a shared understanding of the proper role for GAO, one focused much more narrowly on the critical roles of government auditing and program evaluation. These hearings would have provided an opportunity for Congress—both majority and minority—-and the executive branch to articulate sharper visions for GAO. These hearings would also have created the time and the space to follow the statutory process for recommending potential Comptroller General candidates to the President.

GAO is one of the few tools that Congress has for creating nonpartisan recommendations for improving government operations and identifying places where programs fall short of their goals. It has produced a substantial return on investment, even as GAO has probably not been as hard-hitting as the facts have called for.

Unfortunately, over the years, GAO has been given additional functions by Congress that conflict with and have undermined support for this core mission. Today’s fight focuses on functions given to GAO under the Impoundment Control Act (ICA), which passed as part of the Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974.

The ICA tried to make GAO the enforcer on impoundments. This was an unwise legal structure. This power is unlikely to survive judicial review. In Bowsher v. Synar, the Supreme Court struck down another attempt to give GAO powers that neither Congress nor the executive branch was willing to take. Recent scholarship has suggested that the logic of Bowsher likely precludes the impoundment enforcement actions.

This was also an unwise institutional structure. No one would hire an auditor that was suing them. Simply put, giving GAO the highly political power to enforce on impoundments endangers its much more critical mission of auditing and program evaluation.

GAO leadership has made the right decision in not using its litigation authority. GAO should not be an impoundment enforcer. Hearings on GAO would have illustrated the core conflict and forced Congress to choose its priorities.

The current controversy and GAO’s institutional design are both consequences of Congress trying to shift accountability onto anyone other than itself. And Congress loses its authority when it fails to exercise its own powers.


Explore More Policy Areas

InnovationGovernanceEducation
Show All